“He’s basically a waste of space now!” Jamie Carragher has finally reached his breaking point with a £35 million Liverpool talent. After what he called a “disgraceful” performance against West Ham, the legendary pundit is urging FSG to ruthlessly sell the player this summer. Carragher warns that his “consistent inconsistency” is dragging the whole team down.

“He’s basically a waste of space now!” 

Jamie Carragher has finally snapped—and when Carra snaps, the football world listens. After Liverpool’s bruising display against West Ham, the Anfield legend turned pundit unleashed one of his most ruthless verdicts yet, aiming both barrels at a £35 million Liverpool talent he believes has run out of chances. His assessment? “Disgraceful.” His solution? Sell. This. Summer.

Carragher didn’t sugarcoat a single word. On live TV, he tore into what he described as “consistent inconsistency”—a phrase that’s quickly gone viral among Reds fans. According to Carra, this isn’t about one bad night or a dip in form. This is about a player who promises much, delivers little, and is now actively dragging the team down during crucial moments of the season. For a side chasing standards set during the Klopp era, Carragher says the patience has completely evaporated.

What really lit the fuse was the West Ham performance. Sloppy decision-making, zero end product, and an alarming lack of intensity—Carragher labeled it “a performance that belongs nowhere near a Liverpool starting XI.” He argued that while others fought to impose themselves on the game, this particular player looked anonymous, disconnected, and—most damning of all—replaceable. In Carragher’s eyes, that’s the ultimate sin at Anfield.

And then came the warning shot to FSG.

Carragher urged Liverpool’s owners to be “ruthless” in the upcoming window, insisting sentimentality is no longer an option. “This is Liverpool, not a rehab center for underperformers,” he said, stressing that selling now could still recoup value before the market—and the fanbase—turns completely unforgiving.

Unsurprisingly, the fans are absolutely FUMING.

Social media exploded within minutes. Some supporters echoed Carragher’s frustration, calling the player a luxury Liverpool can no longer afford. Others fired back, accusing Carra of crossing the line and piling pressure on someone who’s already struggling. The divide is real—and getting uglier by the hour.

Then came the most provocative question of all:

Is he really as bad as Gakpo, or is Carragher being too harsh?

That comparison alone has sent Reds Twitter into meltdown. While some argue the numbers and influence simply aren’t there, others insist the system, rotation, and confidence issues tell a much more nuanced story. But nuance doesn’t trend—and Carragher’s comments have poured petrol on an already raging debate.

One thing is undeniable: this saga isn’t going away. With summer approaching, scrutiny intensifying, and Liverpool’s rebuild looming large, the spotlight on this £35m man is now blinding. Redemption arc—or ruthless exit? According to Jamie Carragher, the decision should already be made.

Carragher says SELL.

The fans are FUMING.

And Liverpool? They’re standing at a crossroads.