“They wouldn’t have lost this match if Isak actually played today. It’s their fault for trying to be too smart but fair play to Liverpool” – This is according to Gary Neville as he points out how Isak’s absence has terribly affected Newcastle after their “disastrous” display against Liverpool.
Gary Neville Slams Newcastle’s “Big Mistake” in Isak’s Absence After Liverpool Defeat ⚽🔥
Gary Neville Slams Newcastle’s “Big Mistake” in Isak’s Absence After Liverpool Defeat ⚽🔥
Manchester United legend and pundit Gary Neville has delivered a damning verdict on Newcastle United following their disappointing defeat to Liverpool, pointing directly to the absence of star striker Alexander Isak as the decisive factor in their downfall.
Neville, who was on commentary duty for the high-profile Premier League clash, did not mince his words after watching Newcastle crumble without their talismanic forward. The former defender suggested that Eddie Howe and the Newcastle hierarchy had “outsmarted themselves” by resting or managing Isak instead of unleashing him in one of the club’s biggest fixtures of the season.
“They wouldn’t have lost this match if Isak actually played today. It’s their fault for trying to be too smart—but fair play to Liverpool,” Neville declared.
Isak’s Growing Influence at Newcastle 🌟⚡
Since his arrival from Real Sociedad, Alexander Isak has quickly cemented himself as one of the most clinical forwards in the Premier League. His blend of pace, composure, and lethal finishing has made him the focal point of Newcastle’s attack.
Without him, Newcastle looked disjointed and toothless in front of goal against Liverpool. While the Magpies had moments of promise, their final-third execution was woefully lacking. Several chances went begging, and their forwards often appeared isolated and out of ideas.
Neville pointed out that this was precisely where Isak’s presence was missed the most:
- His movement drags defenders out of position.
- His link-up play creates space for wingers.
- His instinctive finishing turns half-chances into goals.
Without him, Newcastle looked ordinary — a criticism that will sting Eddie Howe as he reflects on the tactical choices that backfired.
Liverpool Take Advantage 🔴💥
While Newcastle struggled, Liverpool capitalized. Arne Slot’s men smelled blood from the opening whistle and punished the Magpies’ lack of cutting edge. With Mohamed Salah and Darwin Núñez buzzing in attack, Liverpool kept pressing until they found the breakthrough.
Though Neville credited Liverpool for their professionalism, he insisted the match could have turned out very differently had Isak been on the pitch.
“You put Isak in that team today, and the whole game changes. Liverpool’s defenders would’ve had a very different afternoon,” Neville added.
Neville’s Dig at Newcastle’s Decision-Making 🧠❌
What frustrated Neville the most was the sense that Newcastle had been too clever for their own good. Whether it was due to rotation, fitness concerns, or tactical reasons, leaving Isak out in such a high-stakes clash was, in Neville’s eyes, a catastrophic miscalculation.
“Sometimes managers try to be too smart in these situations. But you can’t leave your best striker out against Liverpool. It sends the wrong message, and it cost them,” he argued.
For Neville, this wasn’t just about one game — it was about mentality. He hinted that Newcastle must learn how to approach big fixtures with their strongest possible side if they want to be taken seriously as consistent top-four contenders.
Fans React: Anger and Frustration 😡📢
On social media, Newcastle fans echoed Neville’s sentiments. Many vented their frustration at the decision to sideline Isak, arguing that the defeat was entirely avoidable. Some accused Howe of being “overcautious,” while others questioned the depth of the squad if one absence can derail the team so dramatically.
Liverpool supporters, meanwhile, embraced Neville’s words with a mix of pride and mischief. Many acknowledged that Isak’s absence was a factor, but insisted their side was the better team on the day.
What This Means Going Forward 📊
If Neville is right, the Isak debate may hang over Newcastle for weeks to come. With the Premier League season in full swing, every point is vital in the race for Champions League qualification. Newcastle cannot afford to drop points simply because their best striker is on the sidelines.
Eddie Howe will now face mounting pressure to ensure Isak plays a leading role in the matches to come. And while Liverpool will celebrate a valuable victory, the story of this clash may ultimately be remembered for who didn’t play rather than who did.
Final Verdict 📝
Gary Neville’s comments may be blunt, but they cut to the heart of Newcastle’s problems: without Alexander Isak, the Magpies lose their cutting edge. Against a side like Liverpool, that weakness is brutally exposed.
Neville summed it up best: “Newcastle’s plan backfired. Isak is their difference-maker, and leaving him out against Liverpool is a mistake they won’t want to repeat.”
For Newcastle, the lesson is simple — never leave your best weapon on the bench in a battle this big.
