Carragher and Neville completely agree on the main issue troubling Chelsea’s defense.

Chelsea’s defensive performance in their recent match was highly criticized, with all three goals exposing significant weaknesses at the back. However, it was the third goal that particularly frustrated Gary Neville, leading him to voice strong concerns about the team’s defensive frailties.

Neville singled out Levi Colwill, who lost possession but believed he had been fouled. Instead of reacting quickly, Colwill remained on the ground appealing to the referee while Brighton capitalized on the opportunity, racing towards Chelsea’s goal unchecked. Neville emphasized that while Colwill is still young and learning, he and other Chelsea players must develop greater physical strength and resilience to compete at the highest level. He acknowledged that gaining such attributes is difficult for young players, but learning on the job as a center-back in the Premier League is particularly challenging.

Jamie Carragher echoed Neville’s sentiments, recalling a previous game against Liverpool where Chelsea had dominated for long periods but crumbled defensively under physical pressure. He jokingly suggested that the team needed a “pint of scouse” to toughen up, emphasizing that their lack of physicality continues to be a glaring weakness.

Both pundits also pointed out how Jarrod Bowen, despite not being physically imposing, caused significant problems for Chelsea due to his relentless work ethic, aggression, and commitment. Colwill’s mistake in a previous game had allowed Bowen to score, further highlighting Chelsea’s defensive vulnerabilities.

The criticism from Neville and Carragher aligns with a growing consensus: Chelsea’s defenders are struggling with physical battles, looking too weak, too soft, and too hesitant to cope with the demands of the Premier League.