“I don’t know why we signed him. With such a performance, he has proved that he’s just wasted funds. He has not become a better replacement for the player formerly this position” – Paul Scholes expresses doubts about Manchester United’s decision to sign the £43 million player following their home defeat to Wolves.

Paul Scholes Questions Manchester United’s £43 Million Signing After Disastrous Home Defeat to Wolves

In the wake of Manchester United’s shocking home defeat to Wolverhampton Wanderers, club legend Paul Scholes has spoken out with fierce criticism directed at one of the club’s recent high-profile signings. The former midfielder did not hold back during his post-match analysis, making it clear that he believes United may have made a costly mistake in the transfer market.

“I Don’t Know Why We Signed Him” – Scholes Unloads

Speaking as a pundit following the Red Devils’ dismal 3-1 loss at Old Trafford, Scholes highlighted the disappointing performance of the £43 million acquisition, expressing deep concern about both the player’s quality and the club’s decision-making process in signing him. Although he refrained from naming the player directly in the initial moments of his remarks, it quickly became apparent that his frustration was aimed at the individual brought in to replace a key figure in the United setup.

“I honestly don’t know why we signed him,” Scholes said bluntly. “With a performance like that, he’s shown absolutely nothing to justify his price tag. It’s not just about the money, it’s about what he brings to the squad—and right now, I see very little.”

The former England international didn’t stop there. Drawing comparisons to the player the new signing was brought in to replace, Scholes suggested that United have not only failed to improve their squad but may have actively weakened it.

“He’s nowhere near the level of the player who had that position before him. Say what you like about that player, but at least you got consistency. This one? I see no progression, no spark, and no impact.”

A Broader Issue at United?

United’s loss to Wolves has reignited debate over the club’s transfer strategy and the pressure placed on new recruits. While the name of the criticized player wasn’t explicitly mentioned by Scholes in the immediate aftermath, fans and pundits alike have speculated he was referring to a player recently signed to bolster either the midfield or the defensive line—areas that have come under intense scrutiny this season.

The £43 million figure narrows the field significantly, and the club’s supporters are already reacting strongly to Scholes’ comments. Many have echoed his sentiments, taking to social media to question whether the signing was more about hype than actual fit within Erik ten Hag’s tactical setup.

The Defeat That Sparked It All

The match itself was a disaster for Manchester United. Wolves, a team that has often struggled at Old Trafford, came in with confidence and capitalized on a disjointed and lethargic United side. Defensive lapses, lack of midfield cohesion, and poor finishing plagued the home team throughout the 90 minutes. The visiting side’s clinical approach, combined with United’s complacency, resulted in a well-deserved win for Wolves and a barrage of criticism for the Red Devils.

The atmosphere inside the Theatre of Dreams quickly turned sour, with boos ringing out from the stands. Fans expected a reaction after a string of inconsistent performances, but what they got was another reminder that the rebuild under Ten Hag—or Amorim, depending on the latest managerial shifts—is far from complete.

A Warning Sign or Overreaction?

While Scholes’ assessment may appear harsh, it taps into a growing concern among United supporters: is the club wasting its resources on players who fail to make a difference? With Premier League rivals strengthening intelligently, the Red Devils’ inability to get the best out of their signings continues to raise eyebrows.

The £43 million man in question will now be under intense pressure to respond, knowing that scrutiny from a club legend like Scholes carries significant weight. Whether this serves as a wake-up call or further damages the player’s confidence remains to be seen.

Final Thoughts

As Manchester United reels from yet another painful defeat, attention is shifting from the pitch to the boardroom. Who is scouting these players? Are they being properly integrated into the squad? And most importantly, is there a clear vision guiding United’s future?

Paul Scholes has always been known for speaking his mind, and this latest outburst is unlikely to be his last. For the player in question, the path forward is simple yet daunting: prove the critics wrong or risk being remembered as another costly misstep in United’s post-Ferguson era.

The pressure is mounting, and for Manchester United, time is running out to get things right.