Premier League release two statements after Everton vs Man United VAR and penalty controversy

The Premier League was compelled to issue two separate VAR statements following an intense 2-2 draw between Manchester United and Everton at Goodison Park. The match was filled with controversy, drama, and late-game twists, leaving fans on the edge of their seats.

Everton dominated the first half, capitalizing on Manchester United’s lackluster performance. They took the lead in the 19th minute when Beto’s shot deflected into the net, leaving goalkeeper Andre Onana helpless. VAR intervened to check for a potential offside, but after a thorough review, the goal was upheld. The Premier League later confirmed on social media that no offside violation had occurred in the build-up.

Before halftime, Everton extended their lead as Abdoulaye Doucoure rose above Harry Maguire to head the ball home. At that point, United appeared to be heading toward yet another disappointing defeat. However, a stunning resurgence began in the 72nd minute when Bruno Fernandes curled in a spectacular free-kick, injecting hope into the visiting side.

The comeback was completed just eight minutes later when Manuel Ugarte unleashed a sensational strike from the edge of the penalty area, leveling the score at 2-2. But just as the match seemed destined to end in a draw, controversy erupted in stoppage time. Referee Andy Madley awarded Everton a penalty after a challenge involving Maguire and Matthijs de Ligt on Ashley Young.

VAR official Matt Donohue intervened, advising Madley to review the decision on the pitchside monitor. After careful reconsideration, Madley overturned the penalty, sparking outrage from the home fans. The Premier League swiftly clarified the reasoning behind the reversal, stating that no foul had been committed. Initially, they reported that play resumed with a free-kick, but this was later corrected to confirm that a drop ball had restarted the game.

With this draw, Manchester United remains in a challenging position in the league table. Meanwhile, the controversial decisions from this match have once again fueled the debate over VAR’s consistency and its impact on crucial moments in the game.